Program on the development of the american economy four explanations for secular stagnation are distinguished. The cepr press ebook on secular stagnation has been viewed over 80,000 times since it was published on 15 august 2014. Eichengreen, park, and shin, w18673 growth slowdowns redux. We evaluate the global macroeconomic effects of crosscountrycoordinated fiscal and monetary policies to counterbalance secular stagnation by simulating a fiveregion new keynesian model of the world economy, calibrated to the united states. History doesnt actually say anything, but it points to observations, patterns, and discrepancies between past predictions and outcomes which may be helpful for formulating answers to such questions. This article argues that the secular stagnation of u.
Secular stagnation 2 economic progress and declining population growth alvin hensen 1938 9 years after beginning of the great depression wondering whether there would be suf. Four explanations for secular stagnation are distinguished. Six years after the global crisis, the recovery is still anaemic despite years of nearzero interest rates and extraordinary central bank manoeuvres. E00,n1 abstract four explanations for secular stagnation are distinguished. The secular stagnation hypothesis as an explanation of recent economic trends has been proposed, amongst others, by summers 2015 and eichengreen 2015. As a consequence, in addition to the risk of a secular stagnation caused by insufficient demand, as discussed by summers 2014, 2015 or. Secular stagnation meets the headwinds 47 robert j gordon 4 four observations on secular stagnation 61. The long view barry eichengreen nber working paper no. Demand side secular stagnation american economic association. Some notes on the secular stagnation hypothesis stefano di bucchianico roma tre university political economy workshop 19th september 2017 abstract in the aftermath of the great recession recovery in united states and the eurozone has been sluggish and unsatisfying in terms of growth and unemployment reduction.
This important book in the nber series on longterm factors in economic development follows. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading secular stagnation. Secular stagnation 3 longrun potential growth rate deviation of actual growth from its potential oneoff changes in the level of gdp without a change in the longrun growth rate. Any views expressed are solely those of the authors and so cannot be taken to represent those of the bank of england or to. An empirical exploration with special reference to the european monetary system, nber working papers 4898, national bureau of economic research, inc. On falling neutral real rates, fiscal policy, and the risk of. Pdf when secular stagnation meets pikettys capitalism.
Eichengreen 2015 for a recent overview and akyuz 2017 for an informative. Though the consensus around what secular stagnation means is loose, one factor almost everyone agrees on is the lack of population growth that concerned hansen has reemerged as a problem. What does history have to say about the dangers of secular stagnation. The experience of first japan and now europe and the usa suggests that hansens concept of secular stagnation is highly relevant. In general, a marketbased economy affected by secular stagnation is characterised by low or absent economic growth, low inflation and low interest rates.
The extraordinary events needed to pull the economy out of depression as well as the recent weakness suggest that it is worth considering secular stagnation. The rediscovery of secular stagnation on 8 november 20, at an imf conference in honour of stanley fisher. Gordon alvin hansen 1939 popularized the term secular stagnation, and we are now, at the suggestion of larry summers 2014, considering the application of hansens term to the current us economy, because the pace of out. Facts, causes and cures kindle edition by baldwin, richard, teulings, coen. The impact of the feds exit on india with karik basu and poonam gupta, voxeu, 5 november 2014. Several recent theoretical papers, motivated by the slow recovery after the recent nancial crisis, show that secular stag. As barry eichengreen puts it in his perceptive contribution to this ebook. One prominent example of a formalization of these ideas is eggertsson and mehrotra 2014, who show how a persistent. The great recession of 20082010 increased unemployment substantially in the us and abroad.
None of them, however, get at the essence of the mattersince they specifically avoid the issue of contradictions in the accumulation process itself. Issn 17253187 online issn 10168060 print european economy. We evaluate the global macroeconomic effects of crosscountrycoordinated fiscal and monetary policies to counterbalance secular stagnation by simulating a fiveregion new keynesian model of the world economy, calibrated to the united states us, the euro area, japan, china, and the rest of the world. This ebook gathers the thinking of leading economists including larry summers, paul krugman, robert gordon, olivier blanchard, richard koo, barry eichengreen, ricardo caballero, ed glaeser and a dozen others. Pdf when secular stagnation meets pikettys capitalism in. Debt overhang and secular stagnation adair turner senior fellow institute for new economic thinking cass business school london, 25th march 2015. Mar 25, 2016 though the consensus around what secular stagnation means is loose, one factor almost everyone agrees on is the lack of population growth that concerned hansen has reemerged as a problem. The resurgence of interest in secular stagnation is greatly welcomed. Secular stagnation and the relative price of investment goods gregory thwaites november 2015 staff working papers describe research in progress by the authors and are published to elicit comments and to further debate. Facts, causes, and cures, which consists of a set of papers by a group of economists, brought together in an attempt to understand secular stagnation, and how we might address the problem, if it is one.
This important book in the nber series on longterm factors in economic development follows in the tradition of w. Koo, eichengreen, caballero, glaeser and a dozen others edited by. Reallocation of intangible capital and secular stagnation. The new secular stagnation hypothesis responds to recent experience and the manifest inadequacy of conventional formulations by raising the possibility that it may be impossible for an economy to achieve full employment, satisfactory growth, and financial stability simultaneously simply through the operation of conventional monetary policy. The economics of secular stagnation secular stagnation. Hence the title though versailles wears it better and. The pdf remains freely downloadable, but as the european debate on. The third part examines the current neoclassical arguments that could explain the current state of long stagnation, from the supply and the demand sides.
Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Secular stagnation and macroeconomic policy mundellfleming lecture international monetary fund. A long view from economic history is most supportive of the last of these four views. On falling neutral real rates, fiscal policy, and the risk of secular. Each of the pillars of the mainstream idea of secular stagnation brings a hazy focus toward the contradictions of capitalism. Secular stagnation on the supply side takes the form of a slow 1.
One prominent example of a formalization of these ideas is eggertsson and mehrotra 2014, who show how a persis. Secular stagnation, firstly introduced by alvin hansen in the late 1930s, is the low investment demand and low growth due to population growth. The secular stagnation hypothesis as an explanation of recent economic trends has been proposed by, among others, summers 2015 and eichengreen 2015. Bpea conference drafts, march 78, 2019 on falling neutral real rates, fiscal policy, and the risk of secular stagnation lukasz rachel, lse and bank of england. As barry eichengreen has stressed, what matters for interest rates is. Recently, larry summers alleged the stagnation as the fore for failure of advanced economies to return to precrisis growth levels. For barry eichengreen, fiscal consolidation neednt cause a recession, in journal valor economico, 7 november 2014 in portuguese. The gold standard and the great depression oxford university press, new york, 1992 pp. The cepr press ebook on secular stagnation has been viewed over 80000. This ebook gathers the thinking of leading economists including larry summers, paul krugman, robert gordon, olivier blanchard, richard koo, barry eichengreen, ricardo caballero, ed glaeser and a. Pichelmann when secular stagnation meets pikettys capitalism in the 21 st century page 15 poverty is a multidimensional concept which relates not only to the lack of income and wealth but.
This paper argues that the secular stagnation of u. I distinguish four potential explanations for this phenomenon. The honest broker 20151012 the scary debate over secular stagnation 20151001 is secular stagnation a monetaryfinancial problem or a fundamentaltechnological problem. In weighing the question of whether slow growth in europe and other advanced countries reflects some kind of ongoing stagnation problem, its important to be clear on the. On falling neutral real rates, fiscal policy, and the risk. Barry eichengreen, in his blog, pointed out that secular stagnation, we have learned, is an economists rorschach test. Eichengreen 2015 stressed the importance of investmentspecific. January 17, 2017 abstract the widespread emergence of intangible technologies in recent decades may have signi.
The imfs unmet challengeswith ngaire woods, journal of economic perspectives 301. Secular stagnation at the allied social science associations conference 2015, and the oecd 2015. Facts, causes and cures coen teulings, richard baldwin 15 august 2014 six years after the global crisis, the recovery is still anaemic despite years of nearzero interest rates and extraordinary central bank manoeuvres. Potential growth, effective demand, and sclerosis 2 secular stagnation. The pdf remains freely downloadable, but as the european debate on secular stagnation is moving into policy circles, we decided to also make it a kindle book. Capital misallocation and secular stagnation caggese and perezorive 2017 2017009 please cite this paper as. Eichengreen, park, and shin, 20 by focusing on the interplay between the economic. Reflections on the secular stagnation debate, bank of japan, institute for monetary and economic studies discussion paper no. Eprs secular stagnation and the euro area members research service page 5 of 8 this forms the basis of summers new secular stagnation hypothesis. On secular stagnation in the industrialized world brookings. What sets this author apartother than more than 100 pages of endnotes, references, and an annotated listing of the complete cast of charactersis his insistence on contrasting the latest financial crisis with the great depression of the 1930s.
183 1388 1054 1463 224 1292 1176 1141 1269 1528 308 120 150 610 457 35 16 713 534 279 1610 1188 1544 187 1190 981 202 169 1042 818 1498 119 755 61 728 726 1201